It took days of going through more than a thousand customer reviews and conducting expert researches to narrow down the list. Weve included a comparison table below to give you a quick summary of our top 10 cribbage replacement pegs. Its followed by an in-depth review of each cribbage replacement pegs. Hopefully, once you are done reading this article, you will be well informed about cribbage replacement pegs and be able to select the right cribbage replacement pegs for you without any hesitations.

Best cribbage replacement pegs

Product Features Editor's score Go to site
WE Games 36 Standard Plastic Cribbage Pegs w/ a Tapered Design in 3 Colors - Red, Blue & Green WE Games 36 Standard Plastic Cribbage Pegs w/ a Tapered Design in 3 Colors - Red, Blue & Green
Go to amazon.com
Maple Landmark Spare Wood Cribbage Pegs, 12 pc. - Made in The USA Maple Landmark Spare Wood Cribbage Pegs, 12 pc. - Made in The USA
Go to amazon.com
CHH P 9 Piece Set of Plastic Cribbage Pegs 3 Each of Blue, Green and Red CHH P 9 Piece Set of Plastic Cribbage Pegs 3 Each of Blue, Green and Red
Go to amazon.com
24-piece Spare Cribbage Pegs & Instructions 24-piece Spare Cribbage Pegs & Instructions
Go to amazon.com
JustMike'S Set of 9 Wood Cribbage Pegs - Standard Size in Black - Natural - Red JustMike'S Set of 9 Wood Cribbage Pegs - Standard Size in Black - Natural - Red
Go to amazon.com
Haxtec Metal Cribbage Pegs in Four Fit 1/8 Holes with Drawstring Storage Pouch Haxtec Metal Cribbage Pegs in Four Fit 1/8 Holes with Drawstring Storage Pouch
Go to amazon.com
Mudder 16 Pieces Metal Cribbage Pegs 4 Colors Metal Pegs Fit 1/ 8 Holes for Cribbage Traditional Board Game Mudder 16 Pieces Metal Cribbage Pegs 4 Colors Metal Pegs Fit 1/ 8 Holes for Cribbage Traditional Board Game
Go to amazon.com
20 Pieces Metal Cribbage Pegs Cribbage Board Pegs Fit 1/ 8 Holes with Drawstring Storage Pouch for Cribbage Traditional Board Game, 4 Colors 20 Pieces Metal Cribbage Pegs Cribbage Board Pegs Fit 1/ 8 Holes with Drawstring Storage Pouch for Cribbage Traditional Board Game, 4 Colors
Go to amazon.com
Mudder 60 Pieces Plastic Cribbage Pegs Tapered Board Pegs Replacement for Cribbage Traditional Board Game, 5 Colors Mudder 60 Pieces Plastic Cribbage Pegs Tapered Board Pegs Replacement for Cribbage Traditional Board Game, 5 Colors
Go to amazon.com
Mudder 90 Pieces Plastic Cribbage Pegs Tapered Board Pegs Replacement for Cribbage Traditional Board Game, 5 Colors Mudder 90 Pieces Plastic Cribbage Pegs Tapered Board Pegs Replacement for Cribbage Traditional Board Game, 5 Colors
Go to amazon.com
Related posts:

1. WE Games 36 Standard Plastic Cribbage Pegs w/ a Tapered Design in 3 Colors - Red, Blue & Green

Feature

BULK SET: This bulk pack of cribbage pegs includes 36 pegs; 12 blue, 12 green and 12 red. Great replacement pegs for just about any Cribbage board. Love it or enjoy 60 day guarantee on all WE Games products.
DURABLE PLASTIC: Made from sturdy plastic in assorted colors (blue, green and red). These pegs beautifully accent any board and nicely contrast classic wood Cribbage sets.
TAPERED DESIGN: Each peg is designed with ridges on the top to make it simple to insert and remove pegs from any board.
GOOD FOR YOU: Did you know that playing board games can teach important social skills like verbal communication, being patient, sharing, taking turns and enjoying interactions with others? Games like Cribbage foster the ability to focus and lengthens the players attention span. Playing games is an easy and excellent way to spend unhurried, enjoyable time together. They are also rich in learning opportunities.
WE GAMES: Making the worlds best traditional games since 1977. Our games are crafted with high quality sustainable materials with attention to fine details. We love bringing people together with our classic board games, and we know the joy of the game will be passed down to the next generation. WE Games donates time and resources to the Toy Foundation to help children in need who are facing many of lifes most difficult challenges.

2. Maple Landmark Spare Wood Cribbage Pegs, 12 pc. - Made in The USA

Feature

Made from wood.
Tapered peg.
Taper fit pegs for typical boards with 1/8" holes.
Peg colors are red, black and natural.
Dye stain red and black with durable clear coat finish.

3. CHH P 9 Piece Set of Plastic Cribbage Pegs 3 Each of Blue, Green and Red

Feature

Perfect gift for those that love games
Great craftsmanship
Measurement: height: 1 x W: 0.2 x D: 0.2
Information: plastic cribbage pegs. 3 each of blue, Green, and red pegs

4. 24-piece Spare Cribbage Pegs & Instructions

Feature

Made in Vermont, USA
Cribbage instructions are included
Colored with non-toxic color dye stain.
Taper fit pegs for typical boards with 1/8" holes.
8 pieces each of natural, red and black

5. JustMike'S Set of 9 Wood Cribbage Pegs - Standard Size in Black - Natural - Red

Feature

Made in Maine, USA
Fit's Standard Cribbage Board
MADE of Hardwood Birch or Maple
Taper fit pegs for typical boards with 1/8" holes.
3 pieces each of natural, red and black

6. Haxtec Metal Cribbage Pegs in Four Fit 1/8 Holes with Drawstring Storage Pouch

Feature

Set of 12 Deluxe Metal Cribbage Pegs
Size: 1" tall. Tips Fit 1/8" holes
Colors: 3x Brass Pegs, 3x Rose Gold Pegs, 3x Black Pegs, 3x Silver Pegs
Anti-slip design with tips tapers from 7/64", which fits most cribbage boards with 1/8" holes.
Great value with velvet drawstring pouch for easy storage. Happy customer warranty.

7. Mudder 16 Pieces Metal Cribbage Pegs 4 Colors Metal Pegs Fit 1/ 8 Holes for Cribbage Traditional Board Game

Feature

Package content: there are 4 black pegs, 4 silver pegs, 4 copper plated pegs, 4 gold plated pegs in the package, which is an enough quantity for you to use
Durable material: the cribbage pegs are made of metal which is solid and durable, and they can hardly break like plastic pegs, so they can be applied for a long time
Dimension: Length:3.4cm/1.3 inch,Head:0.6cm/0.24 inch,tapered 0.24cm/0.09 inch for 1/8 inch holes.
Features: looking stylish, the cribbage board pegs are reliable and it is the nice board pegs that make your scoring accurate and easy; They are safe and non-toxic so they will not hurt your skin
Fun caribbage board game: cribbage players are fond of the metal cribbage pegs and they do not break and are easy to handle, suitable for family and exciting game nights with friends to have fun

8. 20 Pieces Metal Cribbage Pegs Cribbage Board Pegs Fit 1/ 8 Holes with Drawstring Storage Pouch for Cribbage Traditional Board Game, 4 Colors

Feature

Package include: there are 20 pieces metal cribbage pegs, includes 5 black pegs, 5 silver pegs, 5 copper plated pegs, 5 gold plated pegs in the package, enough quantity to meet your needs, and have fun with friends
Material: the cribbage broad pegs are made of metal which is solid and durable, and they can hardly break like those plastic pegs, so they can be applied for a long time
Proper size: the metal cribbage pegs are small and portable, with the length of approx. 2.54 cm/ 1 inch, head diameter is approx. 0.65 cm/ 0.26 inch, bottom diameter is approx. 0.24 cm/ 0.09 inch and they are suitable for 1/ 8 inch holes
Combined with a bag: bonus soft velveteen cloth drawstring storage pouch for you to store these cribbage board pegs, no need to worry about missing, easy to carry to any place
Fun caribbage board game: cribbage players are fond of the metal cribbage pegs and they do not break and are easy to handle, suitable for family and exciting game nights with friends to have fun

9. Mudder 60 Pieces Plastic Cribbage Pegs Tapered Board Pegs Replacement for Cribbage Traditional Board Game, 5 Colors

Feature

Sufficient content: you will obtain 60 pieces of plastic cribbage pegs in 5 bright colors, green, black, red, white and blue, each color accounts for 12 pieces, sufficient enough to satisfy your needs
Sturdy material: these tapered board pegs are made of sturdy plastic, stable and reliable to use, not easy to break or rust, allow for multiple times of using
Size information: each board peg measures approx. 27 mm/ 1.06 inch in length, its head diameter is approx. 4 mm/ 0.16 inch, lightweight and portable, easy to store and carry
Considerate design: these plastic cribbage pegs are designed with tapered shape which is comfortable to hold, easy to insert and remove from the board, their vibrant and pretty colors can nicely decorate the board, bring your wonderful game experience
Practical to apply: our adorable tapered board pegs are suitable for most cribbage boards, can help to develop your focus ability and attention span, they can also create enjoyable game experience

10. Mudder 90 Pieces Plastic Cribbage Pegs Tapered Board Pegs Replacement for Cribbage Traditional Board Game, 5 Colors

Feature

Abundant quantity: this pack comes with 90 pieces of plastic cribbage pegs in 5 bright colors, including 18 x green pegs, 18 x black pegs, 18 x red pegs, 18 x white pegs and 18 x blue pegs, abundant quantity and bright colors can meet your demands
Appropriate dimension: each plastic cribbage peg is approx. approx. 27 mm/ 1.06 inch in length, its head diameter is approx. 4 mm/ 0.16 inch, lightweight and portable, easy to store and carry, its dimension can fit for most stand boards
Reliable material: our tapered board pegs are made of quality plastic material which is not easy to get rusted like metal, firm and durable, can serve you for a long time
Positive effect: these practical and pretty plastic cribbage pegs can be compatible with most cribbage boards, they can also help to enhance your focus ability and attention span
Comfortable to hold: our board pegs are designed with tapered shape and featured in smooth surface, cozy to hold, easy to insert and remove from the board, can make your game operation more thoughtful, their various beautiful colors can also add a vibrant color to your game process

Conclusion

All above are our suggestions for cribbage replacement pegs. This might not suit you, so we prefer that you read all detail information also customer reviews to choose yours. Please also help to share your experience when using cribbage replacement pegs with us by comment in this post. Thank you!
Trevor Marshall